At the end of the day, it's about communication isn't it. And aseeing as we don't play tourneys, and probably will mostly play each other or some people at the EB, it doesn't matter! If the things we are using are clear, and not muddled distinctions in squads, then it's fine.
It's about reducing confusion because there are so many options for all the squads I guess.
Although I think the rulebook is pretty clear in saying you don't need to be wysi
Although I'd be upset if I was playing philly not in a tournament, and he was funny about wysiwyg with me- in our games last week I used a heavy bolter as a lascannon and a melta tallarn as a grenadelauncher, and I'd expect anyone not in a tourney to let me do that. I didn't have any other heavy bolters so there was no confusion over what was las and what wasn't. if you see what I mean.
Philly, would you have a problem with me using the metal cadian and tallarn sarges? The cadian has a bolt pistol, the tallarn has a plasma. But they don't really.