OK, here's my list idea:
captain sword, brace of dueling pistols 120
champion sword, mace 48
champion sword, mace 48
youngblood mace, mace 21
youngblood mace, mace 21
marksman bow, mace 38
marksman bow, mace 38
marksman crossbowbow, mace 53
marksman crossbowbow, mace 53
warrior mace, mace 31
warrior mace, mace 31
warrior mace, mace 31
warrior mace, mace 31
warrior mace, mace 31
total = 595
14 guys! Captain has awesome super pistols! Mace-tastic!