Warhammer-Empire.com

The Empire at War ... The Gamers Guild => WHFB The Electors' Forum => Topic started by: Michigan on April 20, 2012, 01:42:34 AM

Title: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 20, 2012, 01:42:34 AM
1983: The first edition of Warhammer, written by Bryan Ansell, Richard Halliwell, Graham Eckel and Rick Priestley is published. It is a boxed set consiting of three books:
Vol 1: Tabletop Battles, which contains the core rules, turn sequence, creature lists...
Vol 2: Magic which explains rules for wizards and ruins Warhammer forever...
Vol 3: Characters contains rules for characters and ruins Warhammer forever.

1984: The first edition of Warhammer is extended with the Forces of Fantasy boxed set, ruining Warhammer forever.

1984: The second edition of Warhammer is released, this includes the first appearance of the Warhammer 'Known World' along with a map, and a timeline which includes/introduces The Empire, ruining Warhammer forever.

1987: The second edition of Warhammer is expanded with the Ravening Hordes army lists, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1987: The third edition of Warhammer is published as a single hardback book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1987: The third edition of Warhammer is expanded with the Realm of Chaos and Warhammer Siege books, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1992: The fourth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1993: The fourth edition of Warhammer is expanded with the use of army lists in the form of separate Warhammer Army Books, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1994: The 4th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is expanded with a re-worked magic system, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is expanded with seveal boxed campaign packs, like Tears of Isha, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2000: The sixth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2000: The 6th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2006: The seventh edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2006: The 7th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2010: The 8th edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2011: The 8th edition of Warhammer is expanded with Storm of Magic, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2012: The 8th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

(The next 49,202 entries have been omited to save space. -Editor)

006.M42: In the early 42nd Millennium, the fall of Medusa V occurs. The world was mostly evacuated by the Imperum of Man whilst a warp storm engulfed it... the 24,601st edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever...  ::heretic::
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: arselus on April 20, 2012, 04:52:19 AM
Thanks, I laughed.  :::cheers:::
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: warhammerlord_soth on April 20, 2012, 08:36:12 AM
You ruined Warhammer forever. I hate you now !
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Uryens de Crux on April 20, 2012, 10:26:20 AM
Quote
1992: The fourth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

Depressingly, this bit is actually true.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 20, 2012, 11:15:03 AM
. <----------------------- The point























































Uryens' grasp -------------------------------> {   }
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Uryens de Crux on April 20, 2012, 11:22:46 AM
You dont understand humour do you?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 20, 2012, 11:39:45 AM
My point was rather that you didn't; but if your post was an attempt at humor (rather than what it appeared) then let's just chalk it up to misunderstanding and move on.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Uryens de Crux on April 20, 2012, 11:43:33 AM
Meh.

My funny comment is still also true

Thats why its funny.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: DivineVisitor on April 20, 2012, 11:44:58 AM
...and then folk got over it and lived happily ever after :icon_mrgreen:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 12:23:48 PM
I don't get this humour at all?

Your saying that with the 1983 Vol 2 release , everything was ruined?

That's like saying that Warhammer was ruined from it's creation?!
Please elaborate
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Eighty on April 20, 2012, 12:31:30 PM
i dont know what to think about these replies  :dry:

nice post op!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 12:37:37 PM
whats the post trying to state ?

Am i being silly, I don't get it
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on April 20, 2012, 12:39:12 PM
It is trying to pull the leg of those that complain about the changes to the Empire in 8th ed.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Noght on April 20, 2012, 12:39:37 PM
I don't get this humour at all?

Your saying that with the 1983 Vol 2 release , everything was ruined?

That's like saying that Warhammer was ruined from it's creation?!
Please elaborate

Michigan is a 40K player/WHFB other Army General who's Trolling?  Rubbing our nose in it perhaps?  Pointing out absurdity by being absurd?
Possibilities are endless, though my first thought is probably most likely correct.  Whatever, welcome to the Forum, looking forward to additional in-depth analysis  :-P

Noght
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 12:41:24 PM
It is trying to pull the leg of those that complain about the changes to the Empire in 8th ed.

Ahah Sarcastic , every player moaning when a new edition comes out , I see.

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 12:41:44 PM
I like the new edition, everything feels fresh again
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 20, 2012, 12:43:54 PM
In all seriousness*, let me share a bit of background... I am not as old as some of the members of this forum, and I'm not as young as most of them. But I was younger than most when I got my start in the roleplaying hobby, at the wee age of seven, back in 1988** I was introduced to an odd little game called Dungeons & Dragons. No, not AD&D (that came latter), I had an instant fascination for the hobby - these were the King Arthur stories I loved to read, the incredible tales out ofLord of the Kings my mother had read me to sleep with in kindergarten, the He-Man and She-Ra adventures I loved to see on TV every Saturday... but I got to be the hero(ine). I was the youngest player in the group by a good six years, most of the guys were in their late teens (our original DM was our new 20-something parish priest! :engel:)

In the midsummmer 1990, I was nine years old and a seasoned veteran of D&D... Heck, I was even running my own dungeons! Then my freinds and I discovered Warhammer, then in its third edition.  Warhammer hit its fourth edition not to long after we'd all sort of settled into our choice of armies. I'd already survived two edition wars over D&D by this point (some of the blokes in the original group were still bitter about Chainmaile having become the original edition of D&D), I'd survived a split between Shadowrun and Cyberpunk, and even managed to weather the storm of being "A. Girl. In. A. Game. Store."

There have been five revisions of 40K since I started, five revisions of WHFB since I started, four or five revisions of damn near every RPG ever since I started... and something like 10 or 12 revisions of D&D since I started; There have been so many Secret Inifinte Crisis Invasions of Infinte Zero Wars in my favorite comic book publishers that I go cross-eyed thinking about it... and the Console Wars. Oh god, the console wars...

(Fourty-five minute pause while I deal with my PTSD from the Great Genesis/SNES War.)

I mean, don't let me get in the way of your holy wars... But I've lived through so many things being "RUINED FOREVER!" over the years, that I have become a bit jaded. To judge by the reactions of this games more vocal fans every product ever released is the death knell of the game, the hobby, and Western civilization. Seriously, GW could put a £50 note in every $14.99 blister pack, and the forums wudl erupt with hatred that they weren't giving away Euros, and that [insert any random GW staffer here]*** was trying to devalue the pound.


*Well, not all seriousness.
** Do your own math, but it is impolite to point out that a lady is about to turn 31. :icon_wink:
***Optional: Roll 1d6:
1-2) Blame Matt Ward;
3-4) Blame Robin Cruddace;
5) Blame C.S. Goto;
6) Blame "Evil money-grubbing Game$ Work$hop!"
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 12:49:30 PM
People like to complain , it's human nature!

Your basically fulfilling your own statement.

Your pointing out an inevitability is what I mean.

Human beings don't like change, and are fragile creatures with a limited lifespan, who attribute meaning to past experience.

In the case of Gaming, fond memories of previous editions gaming , are probably the cornerstone for complaint.

GW become the target for the venting of annoyance, because they are the largest gaming company.

It's like when the UK Government change various laws...

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 20, 2012, 01:00:27 PM
Okay... aparently I have utterly failed at sarcasm. So I have to state this is plan language: Warhammer is fine. The Empire is fine. The world has not ended.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: warhammerlord_soth on April 20, 2012, 01:04:04 PM
I like the new edition, everything feels fresh again


After the initial shock, I feel the same way.


Okay... aparently I have utterly failed at sarcasm. So I have to state this is plan language: Warhammer is fine. The Empire is fine. The world has not ended.



Are you sure ?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: mr chumley warner on April 20, 2012, 01:05:53 PM
it is indeed

you have to accept people complain though,

humans complain about everything!

it's life,

happens in every walk of life everywhere

I think it's partly due to the fragility and futility of the human condition ultimately!

deep friday avo chat

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 20, 2012, 01:06:53 PM
Are you sure ?

I still have 108 painted Squat infantry, plus support vehicles, in storage... awaiting their return to the WH40K game. That will be the sign of the End Times.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Phloop on April 20, 2012, 01:08:45 PM
Heh. I rolled a 4 on that chart.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Zak on April 20, 2012, 01:10:12 PM
1983: The first edition of Warhammer, written by Bryan Ansell, Richard Halliwell, Graham Eckel and Rick Priestley is published. It is a boxed set consiting of three books:
Vol 1: Tabletop Battles, which contains the core rules, turn sequence, creature lists...
Vol 2: Magic which explains rules for wizards and ruins Warhammer forever...
Vol 3: Characters contains rules for characters and ruins Warhammer forever.

1984: The first edition of Warhammer is extended with the Forces of Fantasy boxed set, ruining Warhammer forever.

1984: The second edition of Warhammer is released, this includes the first appearance of the Warhammer 'Known World' along with a map, and a timeline which includes/introduces The Empire, ruining Warhammer forever.

1987: The second edition of Warhammer is expanded with the Ravening Hordes army lists, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1987: The third edition of Warhammer is published as a single hardback book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1987: The third edition of Warhammer is expanded with the Realm of Chaos and Warhammer Siege books, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1992: The fourth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1993: The fourth edition of Warhammer is expanded with the use of army lists in the form of separate Warhammer Army Books, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1994: The 4th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is expanded with a re-worked magic system, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

1996: The fifth edition of Warhammer is expanded with seveal boxed campaign packs, like Tears of Isha, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2000: The sixth edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2000: The 6th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2006: The seventh edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2006: The 7th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2010: The 8th edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2011: The 8th edition of Warhammer is expanded with Storm of Magic, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

2012: The 8th edition of Warhammer is expanded with a new Empire army book, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever.

(The next 49,202 entries have been omited to save space. -Editor)

006.M42: In the early 42nd Millennium, the fall of Medusa V occurs. The world was mostly evacuated by the Imperum of Man whilst a warp storm engulfed it... the 24,601st edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever...  ::heretic::

DUDE!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA!!!! so dang true every time GW changes things people cry out ITS RUINED FOREVER ...been playing sense 1994 something will never change  :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers::: :::cheers:::
silly people  :icon_lol:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Uryens de Crux on April 20, 2012, 01:22:03 PM
Are you sure ?

I still have 108 painted Squat infantry, plus support vehicles, in storage... awaiting their return to the WH40K game. That will be the sign of the End Times.

lol

The only 40k army I ever loved and they retconned it to oblivion.

Anyway, 3rd ed WAS awesome, its been downhill since.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on April 20, 2012, 01:29:03 PM
*Well, not all seriousness.
** Do your own math, but it is impolite to point out that a lady is about to turn 31. :icon_wink:
***Optional: Roll 1d6:
1) Blame Matt Ward;
2) Blame Robin Cruddace;
3) Blame C.S. Goto;
4-6) Blame "Evil money-grubbing Game$ Work$hop!"


Fixed that for you.  :happy:

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Midaski on April 20, 2012, 05:24:19 PM
Welcome Michigan - lovely to have a lady with such a good sense of humour on board.

Despite the 'nick' you therefore have to be english.   :engel:






Should we refer to you as "The Lady of the Lake" or would that be ruining it.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Alleton on April 20, 2012, 05:25:29 PM
Welcome to the forums Michigan, I laughed, and though I started later than you (Even though I'm a bit older) I went through much of what you talk about, both with the RP systems and Warhammer. Kudoes, and hope to see more posts.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finne on April 20, 2012, 05:34:59 PM
*facepalm*

(not so much the OP, but some of the replies)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Eighty on April 20, 2012, 05:45:21 PM
Okay... aparently I have utterly failed at sarcasm. So I have to state this is plan language: Warhammer is fine. The Empire is fine. The world has not ended.

no your point was well made, some people just like to be difficult  :biggriin:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 20, 2012, 06:01:55 PM
If anything it was ruined forever earlier than the 2nd vol of first edition. I was excited when I was reading page one of vol 1 back in 1983, then I turned the page and Warhammer was ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Syn Ace on April 20, 2012, 06:16:21 PM
Are you sure ?

I still have 108 painted Squat infantry, plus support vehicles, in storage... awaiting their return to the WH40K game. That will be the sign of the End Times.

I finally got rid of my Squats.  :icon_sad:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Gneisenau on April 20, 2012, 06:46:36 PM
In all seriousness*, let me share a bit of background... I am not as old as some of the members of this forum, and I'm not as young as most of them. But I was younger than most when I got my start in the roleplaying hobby, at the wee age of seven, back in 1988** I was introduced to an odd little game called Dungeons & Dragons. No, not AD&D (that came latter), I had an instant fascination for the hobby - these were the King Arthur stories I loved to read, the incredible tales out ofLord of the Kings my mother had read me to sleep with in kindergarten, the He-Man and She-Ra adventures I loved to see on TV every Saturday... but I got to be the hero(ine). I was the youngest player in the group by a good six years, most of the guys were in their late teens (our original DM was our new 20-something parish priest! :engel:)

In the midsummmer 1990, I was nine years old and a seasoned veteran of D&D... Heck, I was even running my own dungeons! Then my freinds and I discovered Warhammer, then in its third edition.  Warhammer hit its fourth edition not to long after we'd all sort of settled into our choice of armies. I'd already survived two edition wars over D&D by this point (some of the blokes in the original group were still bitter about Chainmaile having become the original edition of D&D), I'd survived a split between Shadowrun and Cyberpunk, and even managed to weather the storm of being "A. Girl. In. A. Game. Store."

There have been five revisions of 40K since I started, five revisions of WHFB since I started, four or five revisions of damn near every RPG ever since I started... and something like 10 or 12 revisions of D&D since I started; There have been so many Secret Inifinte Crisis Invasions of Infinte Zero Wars in my favorite comic book publishers that I go cross-eyed thinking about it... and the Console Wars. Oh god, the console wars...

(Fourty-five minute pause while I deal with my PTSD from the Great Genesis/SNES War.)

I mean, don't let me get in the way of your holy wars... But I've lived through so many things being "RUINED FOREVER!" over the years, that I have become a bit jaded. To judge by the reactions of this games more vocal fans every product ever released is the death knell of the game, the hobby, and Western civilization. Seriously, GW could put a £50 note in every $14.99 blister pack, and the forums wudl erupt with hatred that they weren't giving away Euros, and that [insert any random GW staffer here]*** was trying to devalue the pound.


*Well, not all seriousness.
** Do your own math, but it is impolite to point out that a lady is about to turn 31. :icon_wink:
***Optional: Roll 1d6:
1-2) Blame Matt Ward;
3-4) Blame Robin Cruddace;
5) Blame C.S. Goto;
6) Blame "Evil money-grubbing Game$ Work$hop!"


Would it be impolite to say that your five posts alone make me think you're pretty hot?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 20, 2012, 06:49:37 PM
Would it be impolite to say that your five posts alone make me think you're pretty hot?

Impolite? Meh.

Creepy? Sure as sunrise. :)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Gneisenau on April 20, 2012, 06:58:22 PM
Hm, point taken.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Lord Solar Plexus on April 20, 2012, 07:54:33 PM
To judge by the reactions of this games more vocal fans every product ever released is the death knell of the game, the hobby, and Western civilization.

While that must be the most eloquent hyperbole I've read until now*, Fandir never ever said such a thing.






*99 percent of all gamers had tears of joy running down their cheeks for days on end
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Ol Perfesser on April 20, 2012, 08:07:27 PM
Hahahaha!  Great post Michigan.  I can't believe you even reference the "Chain Mail" rules in your later post!  Ha!  I still have a copy of that sitting on my shelf. 
That is an oldy but a goody.
Thanks for that. :::cheers:::
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: TexasYankee on April 20, 2012, 08:21:53 PM
Would it be impolite to say that your five posts alone make me think you're pretty hot?

Impolite? Meh.

Creepy? Sure as sunrise. :)

Although it may be out-of-turn for me to contradict his Holiness Pope Darknight I, I must speak up for brother Gnu and say he is neither impolite or creepy . . . well, certainly not impolite . . . I've never met him face-to-face, so he may indeed give off a very creepy vibe, but strictly judging by his posts, he seems to be a stand-up gentlemen. And, yeah, let's face it, how often do we get a girl on these forums? It's kinda like when one walks into a comic book store and all the nerds attempt to summon the courage to be the first one to speak to her.  :happy:

To the OP, if you are indeed from Michigan, I'm not buying you a steak . . . that goes to college-boy . . .

And, yes, I get your post . . . well played, young lady. :smile2:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: S.O.F on April 20, 2012, 09:01:26 PM
You know I always wonder how we get to the hyperbole of ruined so quickly....

I think of myself as an old grumbler about stuff and am not a real big fan of the 8th Edition Empire book or the 8th edition in general. I am however not going to argue Warhammer is forever ruined more I look at it in a similar line as being a Mets fan. Just because at times they field a shit team doesn't mean I stop being a fan...
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 20, 2012, 10:47:40 PM
A question I would raise; if she's from Michigan and is in her early 30s and was playing D&D with a parish priest 25 years or so ago . . . who was the priest? I probably know him :)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: stretch_135 on April 20, 2012, 10:52:44 PM
Hands down, the greatest introductory post to a forum I've ever read.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: burdigala on April 20, 2012, 11:41:05 PM
from france

welcome lady of the lake. well better to refer to her like that rather than lady in the lake.

"and even managed to weather the storm of being "A. Girl. In. A. Game. Store." so you will more than survive here on a forum.

and for my self i don't care about the ruined effect. i mourn homwever  the lost one "man o war"  for example and the unsuported game specialits. i was so fond of necromunda  and my escher gang  or  my marienburg mercenaries of mordheim.

and for the squat  keeping  them for so long give you my automatics respect.  maybe more a lady lore keeper  rather a "of the lake"?

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Phloop on April 21, 2012, 05:25:37 AM
I'm sad I missed the truely crazy orks. Madboyz or random cybernetics charts... :(
Now it's too grimdark for me.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Mathi Alfblut on April 21, 2012, 10:32:20 AM
 :::cheers:::

Awesome post! And many of the comments after it just proves its point nicely. What is even more fun was that I realized the original intentions, despite having Aspergers syndrome and a tendensy to take everything litterary. But now all them normals aroundhere was "Yeah, it is true! Damn, GW was evil from the start etc".

Had I not gotten a seriously sprained ankle yesterday I might have jumped with laughter. Also, it is time to dig your head out of the sand, Uryen, and realize your views about as subjective as everyone elses. No need for stating it with certainty. How about saying:
Well, personally I think 3rd ed was the best, or rather fits my style of play better, but that is only my opinion.

There have always been fans wailing and rambling towards exactly everything G have done. Almost as soon as they left the non-profit approach people wail because they wanna make money. Making the game somehow...inpure. But it is the money earned that allowed Warhammer to develop from something played in secluded rooms by seccret nerd group who wanted a high treshhold because it made their intellectual investment feel better, more elite or shall I say Leet! Unless you was not nery enough you did not belong... Etc
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: MarkoV on April 21, 2012, 11:01:18 AM
Gosh, some1 says that he/she is a girl and all of you auto-agree with him/her?

1. If considered as criticism of current players who cry about quite good 8ed Empire, poking eyes of blind people does not make you savior

2. If post is serious, it's pathetic.

Respect for aged Empire player, but i play empire since 5th edition, and i find it better and better every ED. Yes, they nerf something over editions, but overall picture is unique: We can do what others cannot. Field entire shooting army, entire knighly army, entire WARMACHINES army if we like. And now in 8ed, we can field entire Chariots Army :D

So, Empire rules(Thus, negating your premise that world have ended...repeatedly)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Cannonofdoom on April 21, 2012, 11:22:39 AM
I'm also turning 31 this year! Are you secretly me? That would be weird.  :ph34r:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Cannonofdoom on April 21, 2012, 11:24:22 AM
Gosh, some1 says that he/she is a girl and all of you auto-agree with him/her?

1. If considered as criticism of current players who cry about quite good 8ed Empire, poking eyes of blind people does not make you savior

2. If post is serious, it's pathetic.

Respect for aged Empire player, but i play empire since 5th edition, and i find it better and better every ED. Yes, they nerf something over editions, but overall picture is unique: We can do what others cannot. Field entire shooting army, entire knighly army, entire WARMACHINES army if we like. And now in 8ed, we can field entire Chariots Army :D

So, Empire rules(Thus, negating your premise that world have ended...repeatedly)

Grasp of comedy level ..... 0
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Mathi Alfblut on April 21, 2012, 11:25:01 AM
Now, Markov. More hyperbole? As far as I can tell a fair number of people did not agree and sort of got insulted when they realized she was sarcastic. I agree with Michigan because she just hit the nail on the head. Funny thing some folk will probably say:
Yes, most of the sarcasm is on the spot, but my particular complain , unlike the others, IS valid! See the pattern? It boils down to the fact that you cannot please everyone. Not even Jesus could. Hence, what people need to do is to be more calm an see the bigger picture. Realize that this time someone else got really happy and that is a good thing too. Instead people want the game sort of to remain as they want it, and a sad truth is that most people want to believe that they and their mates must represent a majority of gamers etc. Good old tribalism at work. My way is so good that others are stupid for not realizing that it is the truth or the best way. In the end, most things broils down to opinions, but of course, modern mans focus on his or her ego makes for a very narrow view on things.
Even idf the community as a whole finds things good, it is not enough for them because they are right after all!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Lord Solar Plexus on April 21, 2012, 12:36:02 PM
There's a very fine line between sarcasm and polemics. Don't get me wrong, the latter can be just as funny but at the end of the day it remains an exaggeration based on nothing.

If it boils down to the fact that you cannot please everyone than why make such a fuss about the odd player not being content about mortars or Robohorses? I'm sure some here where not pleased when Pistoliers lost their fusillade back in the day. If you must call that cries of the end of the world though...it's just a different plane of reality I suppose.

It's a bit like the media. Some backwater politician thinks things could have gone better, and the next thing you know the party is portrayed as being up in arms about project x or y. Of course they're hitting the nail on the head - that's inevitable when you hit the wall with an 8,000 kg wrecking ball.

I couldn't quite follow your philosophical digression on modern man sadly.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: patsy02 on April 21, 2012, 12:53:06 PM
Funny. Still, it doesn't make the new book suck less.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: valmir on April 21, 2012, 02:37:11 PM
Okay... aparently I have utterly failed at sarcasm. So I have to state this is plan language: Warhammer is fine. The Empire is fine. The world has not ended.


Well, I thought it was funny, and therefore it was clearly, objectively and quantifiably funny. Anyone who says otherwise is demonstrably wrong. As wrong as people who say that 8th ed is better than 6th ed ;)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 21, 2012, 02:54:25 PM
If anything it was ruined forever earlier than the 2nd vol of first edition. I was excited when I was reading page one of vol 1 back in 1983, then I turned the page and Warhammer was ruined forever.

Changed my mind. I have just re-read the first page of Vol 1 of Ed 1 WFB, and the first paragraph is good. Then in the second paragraph, Warhammer was ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: PrinceofPleasure on April 21, 2012, 03:20:56 PM
Okay... aparently I have utterly failed at sarcasm. So I have to state this is plan language: Warhammer is fine. The Empire is fine. The world has not ended.


Well, I thought it was funny, and therefore it was clearly, objectively and quantifiably funny. Anyone who says otherwise is demonstrably wrong. As wrong as people who say that 8th ed is better than 6th ed ;)

You've must have never destroyed an entire Vampire army, only to have the strigoi proceed to destroy yours... I still to this day hate vamps... Though I do miss hordes of chaos, now that was a fluffy book!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 21, 2012, 05:09:47 PM
Gosh, some1 says that he/she is a girl and all of you auto-agree with him/her?

I really, really don't want to get sucked into the trap of arguing on the internet (http://xkcd.com/386/)... but as MarkoV seems to keep bringing this back to me instead of my post... Well, I feel the need to respond. To begin with, I am in fact a female-type woman person and from Michigan. Which of those two makes me a bigger oddity, I will leave as an exercise to the reader. :wink:

Quote from: MarkoV
1. If considered as criticism of current players who cry about quite good 8ed Empire, poking eyes of blind people does not make you savior

It is a criticism, intended as tounge-in-cheek, not only of current players but of a general trend in all manner of geeky hobbies. The original form is drawn from an entry on TFWiki.net (http://tfwiki.net/wiki/Transformers_timeline) listing all of the ways in which the Transformers franchise was "ruined forever." If it wasn't funny, that's my fault as a writer. But enough people here seem to be chuckling, so maybe its just a question of taste?

Quote from: MarkoV
2. If post is serious, it's pathetic.

It wasn't intended to be serious. If you honestly beleive that I felt the second book in the three book boxed set of first edition WHFB ruined the game forever... well... that's not the fault of my writing skill, that's the fault of whoever taught you the basics of literary analysis.

Quote from: MarkoV
Respect for aged Empire player, but i play empire since 5th edition, and i find it better and better every ED. Yes, they nerf something over editions, but overall picture is unique: We can do what others cannot. Field entire shooting army, entire knighly army, entire WARMACHINES army if we like. And now in 8ed, we can field entire Chariots Army :D

Actually, apart from a few games with the bits from the WHFB 6th Edition starter box, I've never played the Empire before. I started collecting my army about three months ago and was pleasantly surprised to get a new book so suddenly. I played WHFB quite a bit in 4th & 5th Editions (Bretonnia), stopped sometime during 6th (all my freinds were interested in other games), and didn't start again until 8th (Old book TK, then Dark Elves)...


Quote
So, Empire rules(Thus, negating your premise that world have ended...repeatedly)

You have totally missed my actual premise: The Empire is not ruined forever.

Johnathan Swift really didn't think the Irish should eat their children.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 21, 2012, 07:33:22 PM
If anything it was ruined forever earlier than the 2nd vol of first edition. I was excited when I was reading page one of vol 1 back in 1983, then I turned the page and Warhammer was ruined forever.

Changed my mind. I have just re-read the first page of Vol 1 of Ed 1 WFB, and the first paragraph is good. Then in the second paragraph, Warhammer was ruined forever.

I think I'm getting closer to the truth, here. Just re-read the first paragraph of Vol 1 of first edition Warhammer and the first sentence was good, but then when you read the second sentence, Warhammer is ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Lord Solar Plexus on April 21, 2012, 07:34:27 PM
Arguing on the internet is an act of cultural progress. Much better than swinging one's fists at someone else's nose or its general vicinity.

With all due respect, but your basic premise is kind of self-evident. If it is of such great import, you can easily count the numbers of positive and negative remarks pre- and post-release. Empire's not ruined, water's wet.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 21, 2012, 07:38:13 PM
... Empire's not ruined, water's wet.

I have a Pirate themed Empire army so yeah, that's true. Or maybe I'm missing the point of this thread?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 21, 2012, 07:42:31 PM
April 20, 2012: Michigan posts sarcastic rant about the Empire and Warhammer. The internet is ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: MarkoV on April 21, 2012, 07:53:59 PM
April 20, 2012: Michigan posts sarcastic rant about the Empire and Warhammer. The internet is ruined forever.

And yet again, no humor. Sarcasm fails :D But, due to gender issue, prep for army of followers! Hope you can handle that :D
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 21, 2012, 07:55:11 PM
April 20, 2012: Michigan posts sarcastic rant about the Empire and Warhammer. The internet is ruined forever.

Oh, flibble. I was just starting to get the hang of it and now it's been ruined. Right, I'm off to read a book. See ya!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on April 21, 2012, 08:01:41 PM
Otherwise you would have ended:

Quote
It finally dawned on me: the first letter of the first word of the sentence of first paragraph of Vol 1 of first edition Warhammer was really really good, but the second one ruined Warhammer forever.

Or perhaps:

Quote
The cover was good, but then, when I opened the book....
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 21, 2012, 10:18:51 PM
Walking into the shop where they sold the book, I remember distinctly (even though it was 1983 and I was 15), was good. Then someone said "Have you seen this book?" and Warhammer was ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Ratarsed on April 21, 2012, 10:36:17 PM
Walking into the shop where they sold the book, I remember distinctly (even though it was 1983 and I was 15), was good. Then someone said "Have you seen this book?" and Warhammer was ruined forever.
Yes. You started playing! :happy:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 21, 2012, 11:09:01 PM
Warhammer was good, but then it took an arrow to the knee.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: valmir on April 22, 2012, 12:25:33 AM
I think there needs to be law, along the lines of Godwin's Law, about posting that XKCD comic. I mean, it's classic and everything, but how can I go and argue with conservatives in the back table at 2.30am when somebody's just posted that...?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 22, 2012, 12:42:42 AM
how can I go and argue with conservatives in the back table at 2.30am when somebody's just posted that...?

Because this time it's different.

And here is where we came in :)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Alleton on April 22, 2012, 03:59:18 AM
April 20, 2012: Michigan posts sarcastic rant about the Empire and Warhammer. The internet is ruined forever.

And yet again, no humor. Sarcasm fails :D But, due to gender issue, prep for army of followers! Hope you can handle that :D

Plenty of humor there for someone that can see it, you however seem intent on turning this into something personal. If you don't find it humorous that's fine, but leave your insults at the door, you can pick them up on the way out.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: MarkoV on April 22, 2012, 04:40:58 AM
April 20, 2012: Michigan posts sarcastic rant about the Empire and Warhammer. The internet is ruined forever.

And yet again, no humor. Sarcasm fails :D But, due to gender issue, prep for army of followers! Hope you can handle that :D

Plenty of humor there for someone that can see it, you however seem intent on turning this into something personal. If you don't find it humorous that's fine, but leave your insults at the door, you can pick them up on the way out.

And one of followers show up! Thus proving my statement :)

P. S. I find that text pointless. That doesn't mean i think anything bad about author. If author found any of my posts offensive, i am sorry.

...must retreat before horde of fans destroy me....
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Gryan on April 22, 2012, 05:16:32 AM
(http://www.howardforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=73781&d=1317712133)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Athiuen on April 22, 2012, 06:31:11 AM
Warhammer was good, but then it took an arrow to the knee.

Hilarious!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Calisson on April 22, 2012, 06:44:42 AM
Walking into the shop where they sold the book, I remember distinctly (even though it was 1983 and I was 15), was good. Then someone said "Have you seen this book?" and Warhammer was ruined forever.
Ahh. These youngsters! :closed-eyes:
Let me tell you the real story, son.  :Ohmy:

I was 19 at the time.
I was playing D&D (yes, the original one, before AD&D, AD&D2...).
At that time, roleplayers were collecting many lovely models from many different manufacturers. We would play a couple of models at a time, and get only the model corrisponding to the characters we were roleplaying: a ranger, a dwarf warrior, a gnome illusionist, a half-orc clerk-thief...
Only Dunjeon Masters would own more than half a dozen of similar minis. Myself, occasional DM, I had around 15 skellies who were acting as whatever troops they were facing - and a couple of dragons.

Then I recall spotting a promising new roleplaying game: Warhammer.
That was in a sort of fantasy medieval Europe. It seemed to be a fairly decent game.

But, probably for the sake of selling more models, they turned Warhammer into a wargame.
And... it was ruined forever. :happy:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Michigan on April 22, 2012, 04:31:56 PM
Well, see, once upon a time there was wonderful a medieval miniatures wargame, by name of Chainmail. Not nearly as complex as some of the other historical war games on the market, but not as dumbed down simplitisc as some others.  Then Gary Gygax went and ruined it forever with a supplement that added rules for jousting, man-to-man melee, and conducting battles with fantasy creatures... and then a few years later, Gygax and Arneson went and ruined things even more by turning it into Dungeons & Dragons.

And yes, I do know people still bitter about this...  :roll:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Ol Perfesser on April 22, 2012, 04:37:18 PM
Well, see, once upon a time there was wonderful a medieval miniatures wargame, by name of Chainmail. Not nearly as complex as some of the other historical war games on the market, but not as dumbed down simplitisc as some others.  Then Gary Gygax went and ruined it forever with a supplement that added rules for jousting, man-to-man melee, and conducting battles with fantasy creatures... and then a few years later, Gygax and Arneson went and ruined things even more by turning it into Dungeons & Dragons.

And yes, I do know people still bitter about this...  :roll:
I had not realized that Chainmail pre-dated D&D.  Maybe I'm not as big a nerd as I thought I was!
 No wait....I'm still playing games with miniatures of imaginary creatures.   :icon_rolleyes:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on April 22, 2012, 04:40:17 PM
I somehow feel this thread has now run its course and is about to be ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 22, 2012, 04:44:34 PM
I somehow feel this thread has now run its course and is about to be ruined forever.

If that's true, and I have no reason to doubt you, does that mean by posting this post I have indeed ruined it forever?

NB: On a side note, not quite as silly, I still very much want to 're-enact' a 1st ed game and do a report. I will get around to it one day.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on April 22, 2012, 04:50:09 PM
So you did! Curse you! 'T will never be the same again!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Obi on April 22, 2012, 05:23:04 PM
I somehow feel this thread has now run its course and is about to be ruined forever.
:::cheers:::

This thread was hilarious, thanks Michigan! I'm sad that so many people failed to see the humour.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: valmir on April 22, 2012, 05:40:51 PM
Michigan posts a thread about Warhammer being ruined forever, ruining ruining Warhammer forever forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 22, 2012, 06:18:37 PM
Michigan posts a thread about Warhammer being ruined forever, ruining ruining Warhammer forever forever.

Wow. I actually get what you're saying! I guess my addled brain is not so addled as I thought it was. Nothing can ever ruin Warhammer anything like as much again.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: valmir on April 22, 2012, 06:21:28 PM
Yeh, it's getting pretty meta in here. I don't want to risk ruining ruining ruining Warhammer forever forever forever...
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Calisson on April 22, 2012, 06:27:33 PM
Yeah, Michigan's first post was full of poetry and creativity, and you guys, you know what?
You are r.... Arrrgh! I did it too!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Mathi Alfblut on April 22, 2012, 06:43:36 PM
Someone posted something on the internet and... well, you get the idea...
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: valmir on April 22, 2012, 06:44:34 PM
Worst. Thread. Ever. ;)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Obi on April 22, 2012, 09:03:16 PM
Someone posted something on the internet and... well, you get the idea...
RUINCEPTION
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Cannonofdoom on April 22, 2012, 10:09:52 PM
Someone posted something on the internet and... well, you get the idea...
RUINCEPTION

...and 24pt bold font was ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 22, 2012, 10:13:24 PM
(http://userserve-ak.last.fm/serve/252/50441183.png)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finlay on April 23, 2012, 10:32:17 AM
John Stuart Mill
Quote
I have observed that not the man who hopes when others despair, but the man who despairs when others hope, is admired by a large class of persons as a sage



I like 8th edition, but I do think warhammer is less skillful and more about luck than ever before.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fandir Nightshade on April 23, 2012, 10:39:35 AM
You have not played herohammer then.....

I place this terrain piece on your unit....you are dead.

I put the bloodthirster on the table.....you are dead.



So far I have enjoyed 6th edition most, 7th was a setback 8th was a step in the right direction with a messed up magic system.


Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finlay on April 23, 2012, 10:49:45 AM
When did we have flying high, 4th or 5th?


I must say that my experience of actually playing properly stems from 6th onwards, and I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment.
Only thing I would add is I would like flank disruption to negate steadfast, as I feel this would then reward the players who deploy and move with skill to get flanks, which at the moment are not overly useful.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Darknight on April 23, 2012, 12:11:36 PM
Flying High certainly was in the system with the very pointy goblins and the High Elves in the starter set. Was that 5th?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: warhammerlord_soth on April 23, 2012, 12:13:03 PM
I think that was 4th. 5th had Brets and Lizzies if I recall correctly.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Midaski on April 23, 2012, 12:49:27 PM
This thread actually finally got ruined when Finlay appeared and then Fandir joined in ................... we need a smilie with an arrow whooshing over a head, (not in the knee) ..........

 :engel:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Walt von Ark on April 23, 2012, 12:56:22 PM
Flying high was a rule in 5th though
6th was best imho. 8 th is okay, its just a whole different game!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finlay on April 23, 2012, 01:42:09 PM
This thread actually finally got ruined when Finlay appeared and then Fandir joined in ................... we need a smilie with an arrow whooshing over a head, (not in the knee) ..........

 :engel:
I got the joke in the OP, I was responding to the reason why people tend to be pessimistic, which Chumley was talking about.
I didn’t read pages 2 and 3 though.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fandir Nightshade on April 23, 2012, 02:22:30 PM
I blame Gw for confusing me and not having a FAQ for this thread out in time.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finne on April 23, 2012, 05:51:58 PM
Well, see, once upon a time there was wonderful a medieval miniatures wargame, by name of Chainmail. Not nearly as complex as some of the other historical war games on the market, but not as dumbed down simplitisc as some others.  Then Gary Gygax went and ruined it forever with a supplement that added rules for jousting, man-to-man melee, and conducting battles with fantasy creatures... and then a few years later, Gygax and Arneson went and ruined things even more by turning it into Dungeons & Dragons.

And yes, I do know people still bitter about this...  :roll:

Shark has been jumped  :mrgreen:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Lord Solar Plexus on April 23, 2012, 05:55:41 PM
And not only once...now the Great White is ruined forever.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finne on April 23, 2012, 06:00:05 PM
And not only once...now the Great White is ruined forever.

Man that poor shark has been jumped more than a hedge at a steeplechase.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: S.O.F on April 23, 2012, 06:05:54 PM
Great White is ruined forever.

I thought they did that to themselves back in '03....oh you mean the shark...
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Midaski on April 23, 2012, 06:40:28 PM
.......but long before that came Bobby Darin who ruined his bite.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEllHMWkXEU&noredirect=1

Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Padre on April 23, 2012, 07:28:22 PM
Shark has been jumped  :mrgreen:

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark for what this means. I think I am starting to lose track of the spoken/written word, maybe it's an age thing?
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Ol Perfesser on April 23, 2012, 07:36:26 PM
Shark has been jumped  :mrgreen:

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark for what this means. I think I am starting to lose track of the spoken/written word, maybe it's an age thing?
You and I both, Padre
 :icon_sad:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Finne on April 23, 2012, 09:24:39 PM
Shark has been jumped  :mrgreen:

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumping_the_shark for what this means. I think I am starting to lose track of the spoken/written word, maybe it's an age thing?

I was just referencing that this thread had indeed jumped the shark, more so with a D&D reference that I quoted.  May not have translated well.  Yep knew about where jumping the shark came from. 
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on June 08, 2016, 08:25:01 AM
(The next 49,202 entries have been omited to save space. -Editor)

006.M42: In the early 42nd Millennium, the fall of Medusa V occurs. The world was mostly evacuated by the Imperum of Man whilst a warp storm engulfed it... the 24,601st edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever...  ::heretic::

In fact, there is only one next entry:

2014: The Empire and WFB WAS ruined forever.

(I bumped into this again by chance, and thought the list warrants its proper conclusion).
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: HoS on June 08, 2016, 09:59:28 AM
Yeah this thread is depressing holy crap.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Peacemaker on June 09, 2016, 01:51:41 AM
(The next 49,202 entries have been omited to save space. -Editor)

006.M42: In the early 42nd Millennium, the fall of Medusa V occurs. The world was mostly evacuated by the Imperum of Man whilst a warp storm engulfed it... the 24,601st edition of Warhammer is published, ruining Warhammer and The Empire forever...  ::heretic::

In fact, there is only one next entry:

2014: The Empire and WFB WAS ruined forever.

(I bumped into this again by chance, and thought the list warrants its proper conclusion).

I always new you were secretly a Necromancer Fidelis!
Just like Balthazar Gelt! you have turned to the dark arts.

The inquisitors will be informed of this!
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on June 09, 2016, 07:26:54 AM
This is not necromancy, but closure...
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Fidelis von Sigmaringen on June 09, 2016, 11:04:20 AM
I came to bury Sigmar, not to raise him....
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Syn Ace on June 09, 2016, 04:10:37 PM
I came to bury Sigmar, not to raise him....

 :lol:
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Peacemaker on June 10, 2016, 05:42:23 AM
Well Sigmar's body fell into a dung heap. But some Necromancer raised him up anyway.

And now we have the Age of Shitmar.


:)
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Zygmund on June 10, 2016, 10:39:07 AM
And now we have the Age of Shitmar.

The OP truly made a point, it seems. :icon_rolleyes:

Looking around in my home, my friends, my club, the not-GW store, AoS is almost non-existent. Instead I see T9A, KoW, some Oldhammer and a rare glimpse of the 8th edition played around here. And a newfound freedom in choosing miniatures.

It was about time to cut the ties to the company. At last we're mature and can enjoy the hobby on our own. Now we only have ourselves to blame if we ruin the Empire. :)

-Z
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Feanor Fire Heart on June 15, 2016, 07:24:18 PM
I feel like since the AoS was released and retconned storm of chaos, not to mentioned ended the timeline for WHFB...its just a way more depressing universe now, and not in a good way.
 :dry:

There's no room for a future, new emperor, new stories, new anything.  Like a nail in the coffin of what could be in the warhammer universe.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Warlord on June 16, 2016, 06:01:31 AM
The timeline was static for a long time though.
I think that has been the biggest downfall of warhammer.

They should have advanced the timeline every edition, even of only for a generation.
That was you justify new character models and rules, various new units, even changing background to reflect a story you want to tell.
That's what I think they are doing with AoS, but AoS lacks soul and depth.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Peacemaker on June 16, 2016, 10:33:15 PM


That was you justify new character models and rules, various new units,

I never understood people's objections to the way GW added Demi-gryphons.  I thought it was fine how they wrote them in.
its not like the fluff was extensively hammered out years before. It was always written in a way that supported new stuff being written in.


But I do think advancing the story would have been great. Even doing limited releases/campaigns for events in the past story, like the war of the beard.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: TexasYankee on June 16, 2016, 11:24:14 PM


That was you justify new character models and rules, various new units,

I never understood people's objections to the way GW added Demi-gryphons.  I thought it was fine how they wrote them in.
its not like the fluff was extensively hammered out years before. It was always written in a way that supported new stuff being written in.


But I do think advancing the story would have been great. Even doing limited releases/campaigns for events in the past story, like the war of the beard.

I never did mind the FLUFF of the Demi-gryphs, I just hated how broken they were on the table and they completely changed how people played Empire.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Warlord on June 18, 2016, 02:06:43 PM
Its not just Demi gryphs, or single army books.
Its also changes in the meta. Time moves on (an edition change) and goblins have improved their armour vs crossbows (or whatever changes in the meta).
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: The Peacemaker on June 18, 2016, 11:25:02 PM
I never did mind the FLUFF of the Demi-gryphs, I just hated how broken they were on the table and they completely changed how people played Empire.

Ah, yes. That I do understand.
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: steveb on June 24, 2016, 02:44:57 AM
Well, see, once upon a time there was wonderful a medieval miniatures wargame, by name of Chainmail. Not nearly as complex as some of the other historical war games on the market, but not as dumbed down simplitisc as some others.  Then Gary Gygax went and ruined it forever with a supplement that added rules for jousting, man-to-man melee, and conducting battles with fantasy creatures... and then a few years later, Gygax and Arneson went and ruined things even more by turning it into Dungeons & Dragons.

And yes, I do know people still bitter about this...  :roll:
Chainmail was co-written by Gary Gygax and Jeff Perrin, both member of Tactical Studies Research (TSR) group. Gary lived in Lake Geneva WI, and Jeff lived in Rockford Illinois.  I watched Gary and his daughters write corrections in the first D&D books in pencil on their dining room table.  Those were good times.  steveb 
Title: Re: How the Empire was Ruined Forever!
Post by: Gneisenau on June 24, 2016, 08:52:20 PM
Chainmail was co-written by Gary Gygax and Jeff Perrin, both member of Tactical Studies Research (TSR) group. Gary lived in Lake Geneva WI, and Jeff lived in Rockford Illinois.  I watched Gary and his daughters write corrections in the first D&D books in pencil on their dining room table.  Those were good times.  steveb

That's a great little story!